Surprising Things That Could Be Used Against You In Child Custody Cases

Contact Us

Family Law Attorneys

There really is no substitute for experience. Attorneys at Law Joseph M. Corey, Jr. P.A. is a Law Firm working with an experienced bilingual team to provide quality legal services tailored for your specific needs at competitive legal fees

When people imagine what they put into the process of choosing who will be taking their children, most people envision the massive variables that include income, housing security, or abuse history. The true situation, however, is that smaller, day-to-day conducts that have an unexpected effect on a case tend to be taken into account by family courts.

In a 2023 survey conducted by the American Academy of Matrimonial Lawyers, 81 percent of divorce lawyers said that they had heard social media evidence mentioned during custody trials, demonstrating the ease with which the behavior of online users can be referred to in court. Even the apparently innocuous actions, such as an angry text or a flip comment, may be viewed as indicators of inappropriate decision-making or instability.

When you are involved in a child custody matter, it is important to keep in mind that every single move, every post, and every message predisposes the way a judge can assess your parenting capabilities and your competence to offer a child a stable environment to live a healthy life.

1. Social Media Posts

Social media may seem innocent to post updates on your life online, but it is one of the most frequent evidence sources in the current custody cases. Attorneys and judges are constantly searching through the social sites to find the signs of the habits, lifestyle, and emotional wellbeing of the parent. Even innocuous status updates are misconstrued.

The following are some of the posts that can destroy your custody case:

  • Images of alcohol/drug use.
  • It is negative comments about your former spouse or judge.
  • Grievances on the issue of being compelled to parent.

Status updates that indicate that they are showing too much partying or inability to be responsible.

Do not write something that can be misunderstood. In a child custody battle, keep in mind that all the things on the Internet may end up in court.

2. Texts And Emails

The things you say, whether in writing or spoken, speak louder than you do. During a custody battle, texts and emails are likely to be employed showing trends of aggressiveness, negligence, or poor co-parenting. Even sarcasm or emotional discharge can be twisted around and put your temper to the test.

When you are sending messages to the other parent and they are abusive or insulting, most likely, you are not keen on having an ongoing relationship between the other parent and the child. 

Note: The judges like parents that are emotionally stable and can resolve conflict.

3. New Relationships Dating Behavior

Naturally, after a break-up, it is natural to enter into a new relationship. However, in a custody case of a child, presenting a new partner too soon or having the child in a series of relationships can be a concern of stability and good judgment.

Courts care about the child and not your love life, but they will look into how what you do is going to impact the comfort and the surroundings of the child. The factors that judges take into consideration during the issuance of custody decisions:

  • Length of acquaintance with your new partner.
  • Introduction of the child.
  • Mom, when, before or shortly after the divorce?
  • Background of partners (whether there is any history of crime or abuse)

Allow room before you engage your new partner in your parenting. Judges would want to see that you place your child before your lifestyle.

4. Money Habits And Expenses

Money is a factor that is involved in family law, but not as many may believe. The judge is not reviewing the income level, but rather reviewing the way you spend it in a responsible manner.

Patterns of spending which cannot be accounted for, gambling, or penurious budgeting choices may cast a dark cloud over providing a stable home. Money pits that will destroy your case in the court of custody:

  • Too much, too vulgar retirements.
  • Socially, wastes money on the road to court.
  • Late child support payments
  • Unnecessary change of jobs.

Do not keep numerous large purchases, and keep them in good books until the case is closed.

5. Placecasting Negative Speaking Of The Other Parent

One can blather their mouth easily when the emotions are raw. But talking about the negativity, even to your neighbors and friends, can boomerang against your custody case. In case the parent belittles the other parent, the court may consider this as an effort to alienate the child or to interfere with his or her emotional bond.

Even when there is conflict between the parents, judges appreciate parents who are able to maintain the relationship of the child with both parents alive. Don’t:

  • Talk against the other parent to the child.
  • Accuse without fact
  • Tell the child to “take sides”

Rather, communicate with respect, neutrality and child focus.

6. Home Environment And Lifestyle Choices

Another factor in custody is home life. Regardless of how much you care about your kid, you can ruin your case by living in an unstable house or a troubled setting. Common problems are:

  • Party all night or with friends.
  • Dirty disorder or disorderliness.
  • Mates who have dubious ways of life.
  • The child is being exposed to domestic or dangerous environments.

Judges yearn to provide the child with a safe place, free of any threats and stress. Ensure that your house is representative of a wholesome, well-organized routine. Even small changes, such as creating a quiet study environment or regular bedtime, are an indication of your parenting skills and care towards the health of the child.

7. Disobeying Court Orders Or Parenting Plans

The last thing that destroys credibility more than anything is the inability to comply with a court order.

Ignoring visitation schedules, failing to obey the parenting plan, and not reporting during parenting time when due may lead the court to see that as a manifestation of a lack of commitment. 

Examples:

  • Reducing the other parent to no visitation time with the child.
  • Missed mediation meetings.
  • The inability to inform the court about the change of work or residence.

Although your reasons may be justifiable, it would also be necessary to communicate even through the law. The court is supposed to make sure that all the parents abide by the plan that is most favorable to the child.

8. Emotional Tantrums Or Bad Behavior In Court

How you will conduct yourself in court is as important as your evidence. Family judges see all: tone, body language, and respect. The outburst of emotion, a roll of the eyes, a sarcastic comment, may influence the court in terms of their perception of my temperament in parenting. 

Remember: You are not merely giving evidence, you are giving yourself.

Tip:

  • Be cool and polite always.
  • Allow the family law lawyer to do the talking.
  • Do not become emotional about something the opposing counsel says.

Patience and professionalism may go a long way to show the court that you can provide a stable and caring environment to the child.

9. Work Schedule And Availability

A high-stress work routine does not turn you into a bad parent, but it may make custody a complicated issue.

The judges would want to witness the capacity of both parents to support the needs of the child at all times. In case your occupation demands much traveling, night shifts, or unusual working hours, the judge might be concerned about care per day. Solutions:

  • Be flexible or family support (e.g., family members who come to the rescue).
  • Provide a clear parenting arrangement that brings about stability.
  • Demonstrate readiness to make schedules more flexible to spend more time with parents.

It is not to punish working parents; just to make sure that the schedule and well-being of the child are of paramount importance.

10. Rejection To Cooperate With The Other Parent

Cooperation is one of the least respected aspects in the determination of custody. Judges seek parents to put their differences aside and co-parent in the best interest of the child. 

When one of the parents will fight never-endingly, will never compromise, or will not respect their partner, it can seem like there is no chance of such a parent cooperating with the other in co-parenting. Symptoms of inefficient collaboration:

  • Inability to send texts or calls about the child’s schedule.
  • Refusing to exchange valuable information (such as school updates).
  • Speaking badly about the other parent around the child.
  • Rejecting the emotions of the child towards the other parent.

Courts will be inclined to support parents who are adaptive, tolerant, and grown-ups.

What You Need To Do to Safeguard Yourself During a Child Custody Battle.

Child custody is exhausting to fight, but being aggressive and considerate of your actions can easily transform everything. The following is how to reinforce your argument:

  • Document Everything. Record every detail of telephone calls, interactions, and incidents.
  • Stay Calm. Don’t be emotional, particularly when writing.
  • Obey All Court Injunctions. Small technical infractions should not become big problems in court.
  • Keep the Child First. Think of them in terms of emotional and physical health always.
  • Hire a Professional Family Law Attorney. They are also capable of assisting you in the best way possible to frame your arguments and avoid being trapped by them.

This is not only in a custody case that you need to consider the big-time issues, but also the minute things that prove that you can parent, you are stable, and you can create a home environment for the child.

Social media conduct, the type of communication one shows, as well as the tone of voice you use in court, can have an impact on which side of the custody battle you are on.

The family court does not care about what is best for the child as the last thing. By remaining composed, dignified, and child-centered, you are not only defending your legal rights, but you are demonstrating to the court what type of parent you really are.

A case on custody is an individual case, and the minutest details may count a lot. Contact us today, and we will talk about your situation and provide you with clear and practical advice based on the situation of your family.

How Joseph M. Corey, Jr., P.A. Firm Assists Your Case.

Joseph M. Corey, Jr P.A is a Florida family law firm that has a history of more than 40 years. They deal with divorce, child custody (timesharing), child support, paternity, and other family issues. The company provides services in Miami-Dade, Broward, Palm Beach, and Monroe counties, amongst others, and it provides services in both English and Spanish.

Child Custody & Timesharing Cases

The state of Florida does not refer to custody anymore. Courts instead develop a parenting plan which establishes timesharing and parental responsibility. The firm helps clients:

  • Develop or change parenting plans.
  • Act on their behalf in time-sharing conflicts.
  • Make up evidence of what is in the best interest of the child.
  • Manage change or transfer requests.
  • Offer advice on affiliated matters such as paternity and rights to make decisions.

According to them, Florida courts will prefer as much time as possible with both parents and will often have a 50/50 timesharing presumption, except where it does not serve the best interest of the child.

Key details

  • Free consultations available
  • Payment plans accepted
  • Accessible 24/7 by phone

Contact: josephcorey.com/contact

Shared